Show simple item record

dc.contributor.authorKubiak, Adam P.
dc.contributor.authorWodzisz, Rafał R.
dc.date.accessioned2015-04-19T19:55:49Z
dc.date.available2015-04-19T19:55:49Z
dc.date.issued2012
dc.identifier.citationKubiak A.P., Wodzisz R. 2012. Scientific essentialism in the light of classification practice in biology– a case study of phytosociology. "Zagadnienia Naukoznawstwa" 4 (194) 2012, 231-250.pl_PL
dc.identifier.issn0044–1619
dc.identifier.urihttps://depot.ceon.pl/handle/123456789/6630
dc.description.abstractIn our paper we investigate the difficulty that arises when one tries to reconsiliate essentialist’s thinking with classification practice in the biological sciences. The article outlines some varieties of essentialism with particular attention to the version defended by Brian Ellis. We underline the basic difference: Ellis thinks that essentialism is not a viable position in biology due to its incompatibility with biological typology and other essentialists think that these two elements can be reconciled. However, both parties have in common metaphysical starting point and they lack explicit track of methodological procedures. Methodological inquiry involves less demanding assumptions than metaphysical, and therefore it is justified to analyse abovementioned discrepancy between Ellis and other essentialist in this context. We do it by bottom-up investigation which focuses on the practice of taxonomists in the particular field of biology. A case study helps us to discover four characteristics of biological typology practice: impossibility of algorithmization, relativity, subjectivity and conventionality. These features prove non-realistic and therefore anti-essentialistic character of biological classification. We conclude by saying that any essentialism related to the notion of biological kind cannot be regarded as justified by scientific enterprise of creating typologies.pl_PL
dc.language.isoenpl_PL
dc.publisherKomitet Naukoznawstwa Polskiej Akademii Naukpl_PL
dc.rightsDozwolony użytek
dc.subjectscientific essentialismpl_PL
dc.subjectrealismpl_PL
dc.subjecttaxonomypl_PL
dc.subjectclusteringpl_PL
dc.subjectsubjectivitypl_PL
dc.subjectbiologypl_PL
dc.subjectphytosociologypl_PL
dc.subjectvegetationpl_PL
dc.titleScientific essentialism in the light of classification practice in biology– a case study of phytosociologypl_PL
dc.title.alternativeEsencjalizm naukowy wobec czynności tworzenia klasyfikacji w biologii – studium przypadku fitosocjologiipl_PL
dc.typeinfo:eu-repo/semantics/articlepl_PL
dc.contributor.organizationMaria Curie-Sklodowska University, Faculty of Biology & Biotechnologypl_PL
dc.contributor.organizationJohn Paul II Catholic University of Lublin, Faculty of Philosophypl_PL
dc.description.epersonAdam P. Kubiak


Files in this item

Thumbnail

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Dozwolony użytek
Using this material is possible in accordance with the relevant provisions of fair use or other exceptions provided by law. Other use requires the consent of the holder.